Are the Imprecatory Psalms at Odds With Yeshua’s Command to Love One’s Enemies?

Psalm 58

Psalm 58:1–11, Overview of an imprecatory psalm

Psalm 58 like many of the other imprecatory (from imprecation meaning “a spoken curse”) psalms expresses the extreme and overwhelming frustration, nay, the animus or antipathy that the righteous child of Elohim often viscerally feels toward the wicked evildoers that surround him, and the strong and yearning desire that one has for heaven to render judgment against those who hate all that is good. Is it a bad thing for righteous people to hate wickedness? 

Is it sinful for YHVH’s saints to desire justice from the heavenly courts for the wrongs committed against them by their wicked, evil-doing and God-hating enemies? More importantly, are the imprecatory psalms opposed to Yeshua’s teaching to love one’s enemy? While this may appear to be the case, and many Christian Bible teaches aver this to be so, we will answer these questions, and upon closer examination, see that these imprecatory psalms express some deeper spiritual truths that are consistent with the totality of Scripture and are actually in line with the teachings of Yeshua. In analyzing this subject, we will use Psalm 58 as our launch pad into examining a larger subject suggested by the imprecatory verbiage found in biblical psalmic literature.

At the outset of this discussion, let’s establish one important fact. The author of the fifty-eighth psalm knows a basic Bible truth that is found in both the Old and New Testaments. It is that judgment against one’s enemies is ultimately in the hands of Elohim (Deut 32:35, 43; Ps 94:1–2; Rom 12:19; Heb 10:30); it is the Almighty who will arise and tread down and scatter one’s enemies (Ps 60:12; 68:1). In the mean time, however, while waiting for Elohim to act, the earth reels and struggles under the heavy and constant attacks of the wicked, and the psalmist cries out to Elohim to render judgment against the ungodly (Ps 58:6), which Elohim will eventually do. At that time, the righteous will rejoice (Ps 58:10). The time when heaven will balance the scales of justice cannot come soon enough for the oft persecuted and downtrodden saints, for it will be then when YHVH will reward the righteous and judge the wicked when he comes from on high (Ps 58:11). 

At that time when the scales of justice are finally balanced, the righteous will awaken at the resurrection to everlasting life and will shine like the stars, while the wicked will be condemned to everlasting shame and contempt (Dan 12:2–3 cp. Matt 13:43). 

In the mean time, the saintly psalmist realizes that vengeance against his enemies is ultimately in the hands of the Almighty Judge of the universe (Ps 94:1–2), for vengeance against evil-doers belongs solely to Elohim (Deut 32:35, 43; Nah 1:12; Rom 12:9; 13:4; Heb 10:30). He also knows that only YHVH Sabaoth (the LORD of Hosts) will, in his perfect timing, fight for, defend, protect and deliver his people from the clenched claws and vampiric fangs of all Elohim-hating evil-doers. Therefore in nearly all of the imprecatory psalms, we see the poet-songwriter not actually cursing his enemies, but rather, he is appealing to the courts of heaven to render justice against his enemies on his behalf (e.g. Pss 35; 40:13–15; 55; 58; 68:1–3, etc.). There is an ocean of difference between cursing one’s enemies and beseeching the just, holy and righteous Lawgiver and Judge of the universe to right the wrongs done against him by evildoers. The psalmist knows that his fate is in YHVH’s hands, and he trusts in his Creator to take care of him. 

Sadly, some New Testament oriented Bible teachers decry the psalmists’ numerous imprecations against their enemies. These same teachers criticize the psalm writers for ostensibly not loving their enemies as Yeshua taught and declare that such a mental demeanor toward one’s enemies was an element of the“old covenant,” and that now as “new covenant” believers we are under a higher and better standard of conduct than that of the Old Testament saints. Such unbiblical teachings are perennially taught in churches across the world, even though the Tanakh or Hebrew Scripture, like the New Testament, enjoins the people of Elohim to love their neighbor (no distinction is made between a neighbor who is a friend or an enemy) as themselves (Lev 19:18). Moreover, the ten commandments of Exodus 20 forbid murder, adultery, stealing, lying and coveting, which, according to Paul, is the definition of loving one’s neighbor, and is the fulfilling of the Torah-law (Rom 13:8–10). In his discussion, Paul makes no distinction between friend or foe: everyone is to be loved.

While criticizing the saints of ancient Israel for supposedly cursing their enemies, these self-proclaimed grace-oriented “New Testament Christians” will also go on to decry “the old (Torah-) law of Moses” that, in their minds, gave rise to the psalmists’ imprecations against their enemies. These Bible teachers sometimes go so far as to declare that Christians are no longer under that “terrible old law” which brought judgment and vengeance on people, but are haply now “under the law of Christ,” and “the law of love and grace.” Sadly, these misguided Bible teachers are ignorant, willingly or otherwise, of several fundamental biblical truths. 

First, YHVH’s standards of righteousness (called the Torah-law or “law of Moses”) have never changed from the beginning of time until now. 

Second, Yeshua the Messiah is the Word of Elohim that was made flesh and that Word including the Torah-law has never changed. 

Third, Yeshua the Messiah was, in fact, the “God” of the Old Testament, who in his pre-incarnate state gave the same Torah-law to Moses and the Israelites. It is very same law that many Christians sadly, repeating the unbiblical traditions of men by which the Word of Elohim is made of none-effect, declare was against us and was “done away with.” 

Fourth, the Bible, and Yeshua himself, testify that the Torah-law and the law of Christ or the Messiah are synonymous terms. There is no antithetical dichotomy between them contrary to popular opinion. Again, YHVH’s standards of righteous have never changed form Genesis to Revelation. 

Fifth, the end time saints are those who not only have the testimony of Yeshua but who also keep the commandments of Elohim (Rev 12:17; 14:12).

Sixth, the saints will receive rewards in the kingdom of Elohim based on their good of Torah-obedience (Matt 5:19).

Seventh, the apostolic disciples of Yeshua including Paul were all Torah-obedient.

Eighth, Paul declared that he himself was “under the law toward Christ” (1 Cor 9:21).

Ninth, it is a historical fact that the idea that the Torah law of the Old Testament was done away with did not come into the Christian church until the middle part of the second century A.D.—long after the death of the last apostle. Moreover, this antipathy in for the “Old Testament” or the so-called “Jewish law” did not take full hold in what would become mainstream Christianity until several hundred years after the death of the apostles of the first century. These facts are well recorded in the writings of the Ante-Nicene church fathers for those who care to examine the facts.

Tenth, Elohim hates sin and he hates unrepentant evil doers (Pss 5:5; 11:5; Prov 6:16–19). Moreover, the people of Elohim are to hate the things that Elohim hates (Ps 139:20–22), and, by logical extension, to love the things that he loves. A cursory analysis of the imprecatory psalms reveals that this is, in fact, the heart attitude of the psalm writers. Moreover, the psalmists are continually relying on YHVH Elohim to be the one to bring judgment against his and their enemies; they realize that justice is in the hands of heaven, not in their hands. 

What’s more, the Bible reveals that eventually, YHVH will judge the wicked and unrepentant sinners and condemn them to the lake of fire where they will be destroyed forever. The hard truth of this message may not play well in the modern easy-believism, seeker sensitive, lukewarm and largely apostate Christian churches, but truth is truth whether popular or not. It is this eventual fate of the wicked evil-doers, who are the enemies of the saints of Elohim, that the psalmists have in view when declaring their imprecations against their enemies. We see this fact clearly evidenced in Psalm 58, for example, where the psalmist is appealing to the just, holy and righteous Judge of the universe to render his ultimate legal decision against those who hate the laws of Elohim. If we have a problem with this timeless truth, then we have a problem with the Bible, the Word of Elohim and its Author. Period and end of discussion.

Finally, now to our main point. When the David, the psalmists, decries his enemies in the numerous imprecatory psalms, it is important to keep several things in mind. The Bible declares that David, the main biblical psalmic writer, was a man after Elohim’s own heart, so who are we to criticize his motives for penning the imprecatory psalms? Moreover, who are we to criticize the Spirit of Elohim-inspired or God-breathed Scriptures that penned these Bible passages through human instruments? What kind of a spiritual pedestal are we placing ourselves on when we do such a thing? Do we arrogantly deign to think that we know better than Elohim or those human instruments he chose to work through when writing the Bible? No! May it never be. To be sure, to question Scripture and its Author is a paradigmatic trap of human self-serving arrogance into which many Christian Bible teachers have fallen. It is from this false truth platform that they proffer their man-made teachings that have made of none effect the Word of Elohim.

Is hatred for one’s enemies a bad thing? Not necessarily. After all, there is a thing that Scripture refers to as a “perfect hatred” (Ps 139:22). But a hatred for whom? In Psalm 139, the author declares that he himself hates YHVH’s enemies (vv. 20–22). If the saint is to hate anyone, then they must make certain that they are only hating Elohim’s enemies with a godly hatred. Since such a hatred seems to be a tiny needle’s eye to thread for most of us, and for fear of hating the wrong people in a sinful way, it is best, therefore to love one’s enemies (as Yeshua teaches in the Matt 5:38–48), while hating their sin.

Yes, to be sure, it is preferable to remain mindful of Yeshua’s instruction to bless and to pray for one’s enemies and to do good to them (Matt 5:38–48). Why? Will it make a difference in how one’s enemies act or treat you? Likely not. However, the blessed fruit of loving one’s enemies is that the power of their angry hatred against us will fail to take hold in our own hearts lest we become like them, so that we too are consumed with anger, bitterness and spitefulness. By allowing the retributive works of the flesh to gain a psycho-emotional stronghold in us, such negative attitudes end up destroying one’s physical and spiritual health from the inside out. Moreover, such a mind and heart orientation actually ends up poisoning one’s positive outlook resulting in stress and fear, which are emotional, psychological and spiritual killers. Love and forgiveness, even for one’s enemies, on the other hand, are powerful antidotes to the infectious and rotting disease of hatred. In the mean time, the saint would be wise to follow the admonition of Paul, “Do not be overcome by evil, but overcome evil with good” (Rom 12:21).

What we hopefully can conclude from this brief discussion is that the imprecatory psalms are not inconsistent with the teachings of Yeshua. Moreover, let us not forget that while Yeshua at his first coming may not have come with a sword to render judgment on his enemies, but as a lamb ready to lay his life down for his people, this will hardly be the case at this second coming. At that time, Yeshua will return as a conquering warrior-king on a war stallion carrying a sword with which he will smite his enemies. This is doubtless the view that the authors of the imprecatory psalms hand in mind when beseeching Elohim to avenge them of their enemies.


2 thoughts on “Are the Imprecatory Psalms at Odds With Yeshua’s Command to Love One’s Enemies?

  1. This is an Excellent explanation of this topic! Most main stream churches and most religions in general have this topic wrong. They focus to heavily on emotions and take a very liberal open ended approach. In other words, it is more in line wth Satans views. As you stated, the Ten Commandments demonstrate love.

  2. To the evildoers, Adonai Elohim says, “My chosen will use your name as a curse –
    ‘May Adonai Elohim strike you dead!’
    But to his servants he will give another name.
    Yesha’yahu (Isaiah) 65:15
    Brakhah, John

Share your thoughts...